The One Wiki to Rule Them All
The One Wiki to Rule Them All
No edit summary
m (→‎top: Changes, replaced: ]],'' → ]]'', (2))
 
(28 intermediate revisions by 12 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Quote|Thorin and Fili and Kili and the hobbit went along the shore to the great bridge. There were guards at the head of it, but they were not keeping very careful watch, for it was so long since there had been any real need. Except for occasional squabbles about river-tolls they were friends with the Wood-elves.|''[[The Hobbit]],'' "[[A Warm Welcome]]"}}
+
{{Quote|Thorin and Fili and Kili and the hobbit went along the shore to the great bridge. There were guards at the head of it, but they were not keeping very careful watch, for it was so long since there had been any real need. Except for occasional squabbles about river-tolls they were friends with the Wood-elves.|''[[The Hobbit]]'', "[[A Warm Welcome]]"}}
'''River Trolls''' are never mentioned in J.R.R Tolkien's writings. The idea that Tolkien wrote about them arose from a misreading of the text in ''The Hobbit.'' As the dwarves enter [[Lake-town]], the narrative mentions "occasional squabbles about river-tolls" between the men of Lake-town and the nearby elves.<ref>''[[The Hobbit]],'' Chapter X: "[[A Warm Welcome]]"</ref> In other words, squabbles over whether the elves or the men could collect (or had to pay) tolls for passing down the river. Some readers mistakenly read the word '''''tolls''''' as '''''trolls''''', thereby imagining entirely new creatures called "River-trolls" that Tolkien never intended.
+
'''River-tolls''' were a type of toll collected by either the [[Silvan Elves|Wood-elves]] or the [[Lake-men]]. These river-tolls were occasionally a source of contention between these two group as they had squabbles over whether they could collect or had to pay these river-tolls for passing down the [[Forest River]].<ref>''[[The Hobbit]]'', Chapter X: "[[A Warm Welcome]]", pg. 194</ref>
   
==Adaptations==
+
==In adaptations==
  +
As a result of the similarities between the words river-toll and '''river-trolls''', some readers mistakenly read the word "river-tolls" as "river-trolls", thereby imagining an entirely new creature which Tolkien never intended to exist. As such, these types of [[trolls]] never actually appear in [[J.R.R Tolkien]]'s writings. As a consequence, many adaptations have included river-trolls as being actual creatures that existed within [[Middle-earth]].
[[File:936_stream.jpg|thumb|River trolls?]]
 
  +
River Trolls can be found in some fantasy games, Beasts of War and [http://runescape.wikia.com/wiki/River_troll RuneScape], for instance.
 
 
[[File:936_stream.jpg|thumb]]
  +
  +
In the video game ''[[LEGO The Hobbit: The Video Game]]'', River-trolls are actually added as part of a DLC as playable characters, thus making it possible that the game designers were either among those who fell for this common misreading or poking fun at this misreading.
  +
 
River-trolls can be found in some fantasy games, Beasts of War and [http://runescape.wikia.com/wiki/River_troll RuneScape], for instance.
   
 
==References==
 
==References==
 
<references/>
 
<references/>
  +
  +
[[ru:Речные тролли]]
  +
  +
[[Category:Culture in Middle-earth]]
 
[[Category:Non-canonical Trolls]]
 
[[Category:Non-canonical Trolls]]

Latest revision as of 03:02, 26 March 2024

"Thorin and Fili and Kili and the hobbit went along the shore to the great bridge. There were guards at the head of it, but they were not keeping very careful watch, for it was so long since there had been any real need. Except for occasional squabbles about river-tolls they were friends with the Wood-elves."
The Hobbit, "A Warm Welcome"

River-tolls were a type of toll collected by either the Wood-elves or the Lake-men. These river-tolls were occasionally a source of contention between these two group as they had squabbles over whether they could collect or had to pay these river-tolls for passing down the Forest River.[1]

In adaptations

As a result of the similarities between the words river-toll and river-trolls, some readers mistakenly read the word "river-tolls" as "river-trolls", thereby imagining an entirely new creature which Tolkien never intended to exist. As such, these types of trolls never actually appear in J.R.R Tolkien's writings. As a consequence, many adaptations have included river-trolls as being actual creatures that existed within Middle-earth.

936 stream

In the video game LEGO The Hobbit: The Video Game, River-trolls are actually added as part of a DLC as playable characters, thus making it possible that the game designers were either among those who fell for this common misreading or poking fun at this misreading.

River-trolls can be found in some fantasy games, Beasts of War and RuneScape, for instance.

References

  1. The Hobbit, Chapter X: "A Warm Welcome", pg. 194