Make another ring

Start pimpin orcs.

Orc Overlords

The Two Ring, of course.

At What time?

Sauron would have no chance to return. He’d be dead.

Of course the premise of the post is kind of ridiculous with the line "beyond anyone's reach including Eru Ilúvatar".

@Andre Hawke what, when the one ring that still existed and not destroyed before The Return of the King, or even after it was created, you saying Sauron somehow was dead?

@Fandyllic Okay, how about I alter the scenario a bit, what if the Ring was teleported by the valar into the void, and Eru Ilúvatar didn't know where it was, unless he attempted to used his power to find it.

@Neosaiyan7 I don't think you understand Eru Ilúvatar. Let's leave it at that.

All right, so the premise here is that the One Ring is not destroyed, but Sauron is somehow unable to get it back?

I think that Sauron's next moves would be to slowly gather an army, build up his own strength, and prepare to take over the world again. He wouldn't be as powerful as he would be if he had the Ring, but he's still plenty powerful.

In other words, I don't think his agenda or plan would change; the lack of the Ring would just make it harder for him to accomplish his plan.