By the way, I know Gollum is not technically in the fellowship, but I needed someone to pin Gandalf against! Besides, he followed Sam and Frodo all the way to Mordor so he deserves some recognition for that at least!
I love them both and they are both in my top 5 but gollum is such an interesting character and is a tragic anti-hero story. Gandalf is incredible and I love him so much but gollum needs some love.