Talk:Orcrist

I don't know this community at all well, but I'm curious to know what your criteria are for inclusion of information. (Is there a clear statement anywhere?) I ask because the vast majority of the "History" section of this page is more or less fanfic (reasonably plausible fanfic, but not more than that). There's nothing wrong with that in principle, but I was surprised to see it presented seriously in a more or less formal encyclopedia about Tolkien. (Do you have a formal way to decide which fanfic ideas get included?) --SJ