User blog comment:Elcidman/Samwise Gamgee vs Lurtz/@comment-182.173.220.129-20120611235159

Lurtx would win. Just through his skill. Aragorn and Boromir were the best warriors there were, and even then, only Aragorn, the Hier of Isildur could kill Lurtz. Boromir was a captain of Gondor and he still failed. Lurtz also has an advantage because he has multiple fighting styles. He fights with a greatsword, broadsword and shield, and a recurve bow. Of course Lurtz would win. If he were in the book it might be a little different from Tolkein's perspective.