User blog comment:Pippinspetfish/Scariest Scene/@comment-72.133.228.204-20120531035447

There ARE no "scary" LOTR scenes. But if you want to, I'll let you know the creepiest one. The Paths of the Dead scene in Return of the King is the creepiest. Or the part when Sam kills Shelob the Spider. Either or, I think those are creepy.