Talk:Thorin and Company

Deceased?
I'm taking out the  "(Deceased)" indications in the "Members" section, although you can discuss it here if you think we should bring it back. What is it supposed to mean? Dead at the end of The Hobbit? No, it can't mean that, because some are listed as deceased who are still alive at the end of that book. Not still alive today? Of course not – that's silly. Apparently, it means that someone read about their death somewhere in some Tolkien book  – which makes no sense because the page doesn't say at what time it's telling us they are "deceased." The only  that could that really make sense is to just list their names. If you want to put some notification and as to when they died, you can put the years of their birth and death. - Gradivus, 05:18, December 25, 2012 (UTC)