User blog comment:Dalledayul/Stupid polls!/@comment-46.129.74.31-20131114144920/@comment-46.129.74.31-20131118172000

I don't think stayed close to the book so to say one stayed closest does not really mean something. Fellowship just skipped Tom Bombabil and other things as I said in my other message the Two Towers wasn't that close as well and The Return of the King just totally failed in my opinion in the battle of the Black Gate. Also it severly altered the battle of the Pelennor Fields, so I don't think any of them stayed close to the books. I did however love the movie and I love the books, but I think none of the books stayed that close to the books.