User blog comment:LotrNERD/Who Would Win?/@comment-69.113.199.241-20120626003947

That would depend on whether Gandalf is the White Wizard or the Grey Wizard. If he was the Grey Wizard, Boromir would probably win - he can withstand multiple arrows and has twice as much skill as Legolas and Gimli; as for Aragorn, it would probably be a stalemate until Aragorn runs out of energy - Boromir could probably outlast him.