User blog comment:Haldirbabe/Haldir hotness/@comment-4390549-20120518012503/@comment-70.188.250.164-20121223191229

I agree, Luthien is better than Haldir. I mean, her father locked her in a tower after he sent Beren to reclaim a Silmaril from Morgoth's crown. Did she wait for someone to rescue her? No! Luthien used a spell to make her hair grow longer, then wove a cloke to hide her beauty. When she was then captured by Celegorm and Curufin, she escaped with the help of Huan. She even fought Morgoth and knocked him out! Plus, she persuaded Mondos to bring  Beren back from the dead- by singing! Mandos doesn't bring anyone back to life. Ever.

And what did Haldir do? Protected Lothlorien. Sure, it's an important job, but Haldir is no where near the awesomeness of Luthien. Oh, and Luthien gave up all she had, even her immortality, just to be with Beren. Now tell me who's better. Haldir or Luthien?

That's what I thought. :)