User blog comment:Pippinspetfish/Scariest Scene/@comment-182.173.220.129-20120606023700

Fellowship of the ring: Boromir trying to take the ring from Frodo in Amon Hen, Durin's Bane Appearing again, the nazgul atop Amon Sul (weathertop), or the Watcher in the Water.

Two Towers: In the book, shelob's lair is is one of the last chapters, but it doesn't appear like so in the movies. The scene where the orc tries to chase Peregrin and Meriadoc through the forest was defenitely tense.

Return of the King- I would say the Othbreakers, but not so. The depiction of Shelob was quite frightening, more so than some of my times in the middle east.