Wicked dwarves

The Wicked dwarves were the few dwarves who fought (or rumored to have fought) on the side of Morgoth and later Sauron, or in alliances with orcs and goblins during the first three ages of the world. There may have been some from every dwarven house except that of Durin (Longbeards) at least in second age if not earlier, but in particular the wicked dwarves more likely came from the houses of the far East.

The term may also refer to those dwarves who were viewed with suspicion and viewed as evil or influenced by the Shadow by others (due to gossip, rumors, stories, etc), though were actually on the side of good or at least neutral.

Background
Of the races, Dwarves are the most resistant to corruption and influence of Morgoth and later Sauron. The seven rings of Power of the dwarves did not turn them to evil, but it did amplify their greed and lust for gold. It is said that very few willfully served the side of darkness. Of those who did very little was written.

First Age
It is suggested that of the dwarves that turned to wickedness (in first and later ages) they most likely came from the eastern kindreds of the Dwarves of the far eastern mansions (and perhaps some of the nearer ones). They may have awakened under the Shadow of Morgoth and turned to evil, in a similar way as the eastern Men did later. But not by the power of the Rings. It is however unclear if these refer to Dwarves beyond Iron Hills (the most eastern known stronghold of the Dwarves in the Third Age)

At the time of the awakening the dwarves had awoken in four principle locations (in the west this included Ered Lindon, and Mount Gundaband). The other two places were the dwarves awakened were further east (at distances as great or greater than distance between the first two locations). These eastern dwarves included; the Ironfists and Stiff-beards, and that of the Blacklocks and Stonefoots, respectively.

However though the four places of awakening were sundered they the various kindreds still kept communication, and in early ages often held assembalies of delegates at Mount Gundaband. It is know that even the most distant would send help to any of their people in times of need (as was the case in the great War against the Orks during the Third Age). Which suggests that not all the far eastern Dwarves had fallen under the Shadow.

During this time there came the Petty-Dwarves to Beleriand long before the return of Morgoth. They had been exiled from the places of awakening to the east. The great Dwarves despised the Petty-Dwarves, who it was said were descendents of dwarves who had been driven out from the Communities, being deformed or undersized, or slothful and rebellious. They were masterless and few in number, and took to the ways of stealth. They were a selfish and self-serving lot who were willing to betray others if it meant saving their own lives (unlike most Dwarves in general). They were known to keep to stealth, darkness, and night. It is said they differed from normal dwarves in various ways: they were smaller, far more unsociable, and they freely gave away their names: other dwarves kept their Khuzdul names and language a secret.

Not long after the Eldar  had come to Beleriand, they only became aware of the existence of the Petty-Dwarves when they were attacked at night, or when the elves caught them alone in the wild places. They were thought to be only some kind of cunning-two legged animals living in caves, and began to hunt them. But this ended after elves became acquainted with the great Dwarves. But achieving that,  and they left the reaming Petty-dwarves alone.

The great Dwarves had still acknowledged their kinship and resented the injuries done to their lesser kin. It was one of great Dwarves grievences against the Eldar that they had hunted and slain their lesser kin, who had settled in Beleriend before the elves came there. But this was set aside in consideration of the plea that the Petty-dwarves had never declared themselves to the Eldar, nor presented any claims to land or habitations, but had at once attacked the newcomers in darkness and and ambush. However, because the Great Dwarves despised their lesser kin, some say they had no compunction in helping the in ousting their bretheren from Nargothrond especially for great reward (leading to much of the kind's direct hatred of the Elves ).

But for the Petty-dwarves, the grievence still smouldered, they hated the Eldar and Orcs with equal passion, and the Exiles most of all; for the Noldar later took their lands; including Norgothond and caused the end of their race.

By this time there were few of them surviving, and they were very wary and too fearful to attack any Elf, unless their hiding places were approached to nearly. In time there was only Mim and his two sons were left   After his son had been killed by Turin and his outlaws, Mim convinced them to spare his life, and lead them to his home. There he cursed Androg, the one who had fired the arrow killing his son to die if he ever fired another arrow, and he also wished the deaths or hard life of any who took his stuff and put him into bondage. He took a liking to Turin, this increased after Mim had learned that the Man had had trouble with the elves who he detested. But Turin ever admonished Mim whenever he talked about his hatred of the Eldar. And Mim spied on the men from shadowy corner or a doorway when they thought him elsewhere. He made them uneasy, they began speaking only in whispers.

When Beleg came into his home and stayed, Mim's hatred for the elf grew ever greater  (he and his last son began sit in the deepest shadows of his house, speaking to none). During this time Andred's curse took form, but Beleg healed his wound. Mim's hatred burned ever fiercer for his curse had been undone (but he vowed that the curse would bite again, and in a later battle his curse was fulfilled). Secondly he was denied lembas (which he believed would restore his youth), and since he could not steal it, he feigned sickness and begged it of his enemy. But the elf refused him and the seal was set upon his hatred of the dwarf, and all the more because the elf was loved by Hurin.He ever looked on with a jealous eye for the love Turin bore to Beleg.

Mim was aware of the presence of Orcs in the lands about Amon Rûdh, and the hatred that he bore to beleg led in resolve in his darkened to an evil resolve to betray the company. One day he claimed he and his son Ibun were going out to find roots for the winter store, he really sought to seek out the servents of Morgoth to lead to Turn's hiding place (another suggest that Mim did not encounter the orcs with diliberate intent, but rather that the capture of his son and their threat to torture that let Mim to his treachery). After he and his son had foudn or had been captured by orcs, he laid out his conditions on the Orcs. Thus Mim gave the Orcs his demands that they pay him in weight in iron each man they caught or slew, but for Turin and Beleg he wanted gold. That once his house was ride of the outlaws, it be left to him, and he would be unmolested. Beleg left behind and bound for Mim to have his way with, and Turin to be left to go free.

For the second time he promised to lead the Orcs back to his home in order to save his own life (albeit he did ask the Orcs to spare Turin). Some versions of the tale omit the part that the Orcs threatened to keep Ibun hostage to make sure Mim kept his part of the bargain though they themselves had little intent to keep their side, Thus Mim thought at first to back out of the bargain, but they had his son and so he was obliged to lead them to his home. After Mim guided them to his home in the middle of the night. many of Turin's men were killed unawares, slain as they slept. Some tales suggest that Turin and Beleg saw Mim and the orcs before they even reached the threshold of the dwarven home  They and others escaped to the hidden stair leading to the top of the hill, some were shot down trying to escape the steps leading up to the top the hill. Those above fought the orcs and died; only Turin escaped or rather as some tales tell was captured and bound and carried off. It was here on the top of the hill that Androg fell, finally slain by Mim's treacherous curse. Beleg had also fallen, or as in other tales he had been captured and bound and laid on the ground with wrists and ankles tied to iron pins driven to the rock. After which the orcs defiled the dwarf's home. Mim hid in the caves, and after they departed he went up the stairs. Some tales suggest that Mim in hatred attempted to steal Beleg's sword from the fallen dwarf, preparing to kill Beleg who had fallen but had not died, but the elf resisted, the elf declared that the house of Hador would take vengence on the dwarf. Other versions the dwarf went before Beleg unmoving and prostrate and gloated over him with a sharp knife. Androg who  lay dying from Mim's cursed seized a sword (perhaps's Beleg's) and was the one who thrust at Mim, and with his last strength freed the elf from his bonds (but his injuries could not be healed by the elf, and Mim had his way). In anycase wherever the slash came from, Mim fled in terror before he himself could be killed.

Following departure of Glaurung and death of Túrin Turambar, Mim found his way to Nargothrond, and took possession of the ruined halls; in greed he fingered the gold and gems; letting them run through his hands .He was left alone for people feared the spirit of Glaurung and his very memory. That was until the coming of Húrin, his father who in vengeance came to slay the dwarf. Though Mim besought for mercy in fear, he was slain on the spot before the doors of Nargothrond. The house of Hador had been avenged for Mîm's treachery and deceit. However, there, some say, the curse that Mîm laid upon the gold at his death ‘came upon the possessors in this wise. The treasure of Nargothrond was brought Doriath, where eventually the gold was a reason for the Sack of Doriath and the death of Thingol.

Thus was one of the earliest accounts of wicked dwarves making alliances with orcs and goblins, though the union was unfriendly and treacherous.

Second Age
Of the seven houses few fought on either side during the Last Alliance at the end of the Second Age, and is known that none from the Longbeards, the House of Durin ever fought on the side of evil.

It is not known how many or from what houses fought on the side of Darkness, but the likely culprits likely originated from the eastern dwarven houses, some fewer still from the western  houses (and perhaps if there were any others left of the those who had been exiled in earlier ages akin to the extinct Petty-dwarves).

Otherwise very little is known about the dwarves of this age other than the rise and fall of the Longbeards who although influenced by the Dwarven ring of their people by greed, and began to fall into ruin, they never turned to darkness and served Sauron. Durin III was in power around the year 1600 of the Second Age. He was gifted with the seventh and most powerful of the Dwarven Rings of Power. It was the Elven smith Celebrimbor and not Sauron who gave him the ring. The rings of power did not have the effects that Sauron had intended, possibly because Aulë had made the dwarves especially resistant to evil domination. The only apparent effect of the Dwarven rings was that the Dwarves became more greedy with gold lust, but they were not turned into wraiths like men. Sauron tried to recover the rings. Two he reclaimed fairly soon and four ended up in dragon hordes.

50,000 of Durin's folk helped the Last Alliance, and alone of the Dwarf clans none of that folk served Sauron.

Third Age
During the early parts of the Third Age (or at least in legends of the previous), it is known that in some places wicked dwarves had made alliances with the goblins and orcs. Hobbits of the Third Age are said to have encountered hostile dwarves of which they feared and had little trust. It is possible that these may have included the wicked dwarves that had made alliances with the goblins and orcs just before the rise of Dol Guldur. Because Dwarves are not evil by nature, few ever served the Enemy of their own free will (though rumors of Men suggest the total was greater).

While a few of the dwarves from the East may have served the Enemy during the War of the Ring, the hobbits of the shire encountered an unusual number of strange dwarves from the east who were trying to flee West from Mordor's influence (as was also noted in Bree). These may have fled from as east as the Iron Hills to further east (and including from the last two places of awakening). It may suggest that the bulk of the good dwarves left the bad lands, leaving any evil ones behind.

Enmity between the Free Peoples
Throughout the various Ages, since the Awakening of the Dwarves, there has been some enmity between the Free Peoples of Middle-earth over various and often petty reasons. The enmity was not always caused by Morgoth (or later Sauron and Saruman) but it benefited him. The Dwarves were not immune to this enmity either causing suspicion among others, or distrusting others themselves (which may have led to rumors and stories of them being evil among some Men, and other races).

Some of the dwarves accused of fighting on the side of darkness may have been in conflict due to enmity between the races due to misunderstandings and suspicion. This may apply to the Petty-Dwarves who became distrustful and had great hatred of the Elves because most of their kind was wiped out, and also between them and other dwarves since they had been exiled by the other clans. Nor did they tend to get along with the humans either. In particular the Petty-Dwarves are said to love on but themselves, they hated the Orcs and Eldar with equal passion, and the Exiles most of al, for the Noldar had stolen their lands and their homes; the Petty-Dwarves had first discovered Nargothrond, and delved its riches. When the Edain first encountered the Dwarves in Beleriand (Longbeards in particular), they distrusted the Dwarves fearing they were under the Shadow of Morgoth, but discovered they were not and agreed and were happy of their later alliance during the Second Age, leading to esteem and friendship. It was said there was little love between the Dwarves and some of the Nolder, as the dwarves were quick to resentment, and Caranthir was haughty and had scorn for the physical appearance of the dwarves. Still they maintained an alliance for a while. To the hobbits, dwarves both friendly or hostile were aliens to them,  and most relations were uneasy and clouded by fear. It is said that less than decent dwarves do not get along with the elves, the more decent ones consider the elves foolish or become annoyed (for they tease and laugh at them, and most of all at their beards).

In some cases there was enmity between the races caused by the greed and envy; men lusting after the dwarves' wealth and their handiwork, and possibly between the Dwarven clans themselves. In one story,  Fram is said to have sent the teeth of Scatha to the dwarves, after the requested their treasures be returned. It is said that they saw this as a great insult and killed Fram causing loss of love between dwarves and Rohan. Many of the dwarves had become nomadic merchants and smiths without a home wandering and tresspassing through foreign and private lands (which may have been viewed with suspicion in some places). There was definitely emnity between the Great Dwarves and the Petty-Dwarves over various reasons.

Still others became estranged from each other for other reasons; the rise of the enmity and distrust between dwarves and elves after the dealings between dwarves and King Thingol ended with the Fall of Doriath, and after the fall of Khazad-dum. Leading to battles between the races. What may at times have been fought in self-defense may be seen as an evil action by the opposing force (for example distrust of the wood-elves of Mirkwood and Thorin's party). But in these cases those involved were never allied with the Enemy or his ambassadors (though the wars between the Free Peoples may have worked to his advantage). The trust and interaction between elves and dwarves was later restored through the friendship of Legolas and Gimli. Other minor and petty reasons some dwarves did not get along with elves in the Third Age was the fact that the elves teased them, especially for their beards (the most decent of dwarves called the elves foolish or got annoyed).

The Book of Lost Tales

 * Of note the Appendices of LOTR refers in one part refers to The Book of Lost Tales as a source for some of the information (on a topic unrelated to this subject), a note added in The Book of Lost Tales, Part II, may suggest that the "tales of Men" that suggest that dwarves are evil, may be in reference to the The Book of Lost Tales. The History of the Hobbit also nods to this by pointing out an 'elvish' bias (anti-dwarf bias) in the text of the Lost Tales. As such the the books may be legends that have been twisted over time in and retellings as passed down by Men.


 * Thus from those Men's perspective in telling the story the dwarves involved in early history were 'evil', but it is not the case that all dwarves were evil. It may very well be the source of the idea of wicked dwarves and Goblins in alliances and not so decent dwarves as mentioned in The Hobbit. So it maybe said that some of the material is based on 'truth (but only refers to a few 'bad dwarves', or dwarves thought to be bad, rather than the dwarven race as a whole)', but incomplete knowledge of the actual events and names. What follows is additional information included in those tellings;.


 * In the Book of Lost Tales, the Dwarves are always portrayed as an evil people. The term 'dwarf-natured' (nauglafel) meaning mean, avaricious, representing the personality of the dwarves as viewed by others (this is not entirely outside the bounds of opinions of Dwarves by other races in later years, by those who do not fully understand them). As noted previously, greed-induced by the Dwarven Rings of Power, and some hostility with the Free Peoples could be seen as mean and full of avarice. It is noted that even in published Silmarillion they are portrayed as having dour and hidden natures in their 'unloveliness'.
 * The term Nauglith appears to be both a term for Dwarves in general, and possibly also those later known as Petty-dwarves. The Indravang refers to those later known as the Longbeards.

The earliest known legends suggest that Melko created the Uvanimor, bred from the earth, who were monsters, giants, ogres, the Nautar and the Naugleth. The Dwarves appear to be one of the Uvanimor related to Goblins. Fangli/Fankil/Fukil (perhaps Sauron), the child of Melko and his servent, entered into the world perverting men. They fought the Ilkorins (elves). The Ermon (Edain?) allied with Nuin at the Battle of Palisor. Fangli's forces were either defeated, but some may have fled away becoming wild and savage tribes who worshiped Fangli and Melko. Thereafter Pelisor was possessed by Fangli and his hosts of Naugleth (or Dwarves). Later Fankil with the Dwarves and Goblins went among Men, and bred estrangement between them and the elves; and many Men aided the Dwarves. Such that only the Ermon alone stood by the fairies in the first war of Goblins and Elves (aka Dwarves and Men).

The Nauglith are the kin of the Indrafangs/Indravangs (the Longbeards). The dwarves are a strange race and none knew exactly where the came from. They served neither Melko, nor Manwe, and they had no concern for Elves or men. Some claim they had not heard of Iluvitar, or in hearing disbelieve. In crafts and sciences and in the knowledge of virtues of all things in the earth or under the water none excel them; yet they dwelt beneath the ground in caves and tunneled towns; Nogrod was the mightiest of these. It is said they are very old, and that no child comes among them, nor are they able to laugh. They are squat ins stature, and yet are strong, and their beards reach to their toes. However, the beards of the Indrafangs are the longest of all, forked, and they bound them to their middles as they walked abroid. All these creatures have Men called dwarves, and they say that crafts and cunning surpass that of the Gnomes (Noldor elves), there is however little beauty in their works. It is said that some of the Gnomes joined in league with the Dwarves of Nogrod. The Dwarves were freely in trade with the Noldoli selling swords, coats of mail, and other smithwork of great skill. There was a great traffic between the people, and also with the Orcs and soldiers of Melko as well.

The dwarves desired the gold of the elves, and asked the king to allow them to work their craft on their treasuries. It was agreed under the guidance of Ufedhin the Noldoli (and his own craft skill), that the gold and one of the Silmarils would be loaned to the dwarves in Norgrod to work their skills on. To which the Dwarves claimed they would fashion things for the adornment of the king and queen such that they had never seen, nor any Gnome or Dwarf had made yet.

The king broke his agreement with Ufedhin and the dwarves, capturing them. Telling them they would remain hostages until the treasures had been returned to his halls. He mistrusted them and thought they were thieves, or that their greed would turn them into thieves. In place of Ufedhin the gold was brought to Nogrod by one of the craftmen's companions. Meanwhile Ufedhin manipulated the king with descriptions of the treasures they would make, and began to weave dark plots in order to ensnare the king in avarice and revenge for his capture.

In these legends, Mîm the fatherless is the captain of the guard of Glorund the Drake (later known as Glauring) one of the greater minions of Melko. Mîm is put in charge of guarding the great dragon's treasure in his absence. Following Glorund's death by Turin, Urin comes to Glauring's hoard. Mîm uses dark spells to curse the treasures so that no others may touch it without troubles following them. Urin smites him soon after the curse, and takes the treasures back with him to Doriath.

The Hoard
The poem the horde from The Adventures of Tom Bombadil also seems to make a nod at darker aspect of Dwarves greed as viewed from Rivendell, Elvish, and Numenorian lore concerning the heroic days at the end of the First Age (echoing bits of the tale of Turin and Mim the Dwarf).

In the first part of the poem Dwarves and Dragons are compared, with implication that dwarves may have been carved from the pit (perhaps akin to the legends of men, and in Book of Lost Tales that they formed from the earth), and Dragons spawned from Hell.

The poem goes onto describe the greed and fall of the Shadow over the Elvenhome, and the treasures they piled up in dark holes. An old dwarf (apparently Mîm the Dwarf or similar) apparently moves into the dark cave (apparently taken over from elven kings before him), with avarice, he holds onto his gotten treasures of silver and gold. In that cave he worked his fingers to the bone forging coins, and necklaces (described as 'strings of rings'), thought he could buy the power of the kings (he had essentially made himself a king). But as he worked his eyes grew dim and his ears dull, and his skin turned yellow on his old skull. His bony fingered claws had a pale sheen. He could no longer see the jewels he was working on. He couldn't hear the dragon (apparently "Glaurung") that entered his door, where he died alone in the dragon's fire, his bones were turned to ashes. Later the dragon would then be slain by a warrior (Turin as noted).

One strange aspect of this version of the tale besides "Mîm" being killed by the Dragon, by the descriptions he may have already died. As it seems to describe his flesh decomposing from his bone before he is actually 'killed'. Yet he is ultimately slain by the dragon. Perhaps it is suggesting his greed lead to a kind of physical undeath on him, ultimately destroyed by dragon fire.

The theme of the poem is kings falling to greed, and then ultimately into darkness, only for their treasure to be captured by a new 'ruler or king', who also falls into darkness, and the treasure falls into the hands of the next king. As if there is a curse on the treasure horde.

Behind the scenes
The term 'wicked dwarves' originates from the Hobbit in reference to certain dwarves that made alliances with goblins.

In addition is an offhanded remark in relation to dwarves and their emnity with the elves that ponts out there is a difference between  'decent dwarves' and other dwarves (who are apparently not so decent). Although the reason for their dislike is rather 'tame' is inspired by frivolous elves in the Book of Lost Tales and The Father Christmas Letters of Edwardian and Georgian fairy sentimentality. Their personality as shown in the hobbit represented the last appearance of "elves as faeries" in the main line of the legendarium, as Tolkien focused later primarily on medieval style elves. (in comparison to the more mature writings later written).

"Dwarves don’t get on well with them. Even decent enough dwarves like Thorin and his friends think them foolish (which is a very foolish thing to think), or get annoyed with them. For some elves tease them and laugh at them, and most of all at their beards."

An early draft of the Hobbit when Tolkien 's dwarves underwent a transformation into 'decent enough people', if "commercial-minded" states in regards to goblins and dwarves;

"They did not hate dwarves especially; in some parts wicked dwarves had even made alliances with them."

This may have been a reference to early versions of the The Fall of Gondolin in which Goblins fought alongside balrogs and dragons in sacking Gondolin, and goblin-mercenaries aiding dwarves in looting Artanor (precursor to Thingol's Thousand Caves of Menegroth in Doriath) from The Book of Lost Tales.

"Thus Naugladur, the dwarf-lord of Nogrod, hires Orc mercenaries to aid in the assault on Artanor, and in the outlines for the unfinished ‘Gilfanon’s Tale’ it is a host of Dwarves and Goblins in the service of Melko-Morgoth who attack the first Men and their elven allies in the Battle of Palisor."

Further aspects of the dwarves association in the past with darkness as spellcasters and sorcerers of dark curses and malefic magic (as seen in the story of Mim) in an early draft the book described;

"...buried them very secretly not far from the track by the river, with a deal of spells and curses over them, just in case."

"The Tale of Turambar’s portrayal of Mîm the Fatherless, the first dwarf of note in the legendarium, establishes Tolkien’s dwarves as guardians of vast treasure-hoards as well as the originators of inimical curses. The image of ‘an old misshapen dwarf who sat ever on the pile of gold singing black songs of enchantment to himself’ and who ‘by many a dark spell . . . bound it to [him]self'."

This is only hinted at in the final version;

"...putting a great many spells over them,.."

"The dwarves of yore made mighty spells,"

In some of Tolkien's earliest writings Dwarves were a mostly evil race created by Melko/Melkor, as seen in the The Book of Lost Tales. In those early versions there were but two races of dwarves (a concept that made it into early drafts of the Hobbit, though later revised to seven). .But this idea was revised in later writings. A few of these ideas were reused in the history of the Petty-dwarves. Although they were not evil (however selfish and would make deals with any side to protect their own lives), but misunderstood tragic individuals hunted by those who thought them monsters or stupid creatures.

In The History of the Hobbit it is ntoed that the The Book of Lost Tales is filled with 'elvish' bias (and thus is more anti-dwarf, than the more equitable narrative in The Hobbit). Thus like the explanation stories told by Men that denegrated Dwarves accusing them of evil, so to did the elves tell negative stories about the dwarves as well. Which may explain why some of the early stories paints the dwarves in a more negative light.

"Here we see the ‘elvish’ bias of the Lost Tales at its most blatant (a bias altogether missing from the more equitable narrative of The Hobbit), with the elvish narrator of the Tale unwilling even to unwilling even to give the dwarves credit for creating beautiful objects without elven help."

It is also mentioned in the History of the Hobbit, that the Hobbit predates the stories of Aule's creations of the dwarves in the later Quenta. Thus it makes references to some of the earlier legends in earlier versions of the Quenta or Lost Tales on the formation of the dwarves. As such while it may have been written after he was moving away from the idea that the Dwarves were created from the earty by Melko/Morgoth. He still was toying with the idea of dwarves having been formed from stone, and it is mentioned within the text. The story did however lean away from Dwarves having any connection to Melkor but more of a neutral race tied to no powers (he had been moving into early versions of the Quenta at the time). However, the story does make some of the earliest references to female dwarves ("nieces" and the mother of Fili and Kili) suggesting that they do not all arise from stone. In LOTR the idea that they were formed from stone would be described to be rumors and legends by other races, and not based the the truth as they know it.

In earlier versions of the Silmarillion as detailed in The History of Middle-earth series, Mîm the Dwarf was a much more evil character, who was a minion of Glaudring, and actively betrayed Túrin (the latter idea was resurrected in the complete published The Children of Hurin). But as dwarves gradually changed in Tolkien's writings from evil orc-like beings to the dwarves they later became, Mîm's character was changed, and in the final texts he is no longer a true villain, but almost a tragic character in his own right. However,  the Children of Hurin restores some of the darker aspects of Mim's story and his selfish and evil nature, and turning towards the darkness, but leaves some details ambiguous referencing two versions of the same account in the same story with an account more sympathetic to the dwarf in the footnotes.

Dwarves become actively involved on the side of Melko, during the Battle of Palisor, the death of King Tinwelent, and the Fall of Gondolin in the earliest writings. Though at times they seem to be working of their own will, and betray others, and befriending other evil forces. This is described as "drawn more nigh in friendship to the kind of Melko."

These dwarves do not appear to always be evil, but sometimes neutral, they are said to neither serve Melko nor Manwe. But they start to lean ever closer to Melko due to their avarice, greed, and sense of revenge to anyone who wrongs them. This ultimately leads to them becoming a for e of darkness that is always at odds with the elves for all times to come. The neutral evil persists in Tolkien's writings as late as some of the material associated with the Lost Road.

Several things of note from this later published versions of Mim's story as they appear in the Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, Children of Hurin, and the latter two books of the HoMe series. Is that Petty-dwarves are portrayed as a race of dwarves that was actively neutral in the War hating both sides. Having decended from some of the more ill-virtued of dwarves who had been exiled for their slothful, and rebellious, and darker behaviour. They were selfish and greedy, stealthy and treacherous (ambushing others from darkness and night). But they were also more concerned with their own success and well-being and willing to betray others in order to stay alive. They are also willingly issue dark curses on those who injure them. The Children of Hurin leaves things somewhat more ambigious mentioning both tales that Mim was ambitious, devious and with a mind for betrayal, as well as greedy willing to turn over others for riches, whose heart had darkened and he had become evil (but also sympathetically mentions that some tales suggest that his betrayal was initially unintended). He is however, not as dark as the lieutenant figure who guarded Glaudron's treasure, and used dark magic to curse treasures with wards. Even still there is the question if he ever did put the curse on the treasure upon his death at Huron's hands.

In Other Media
The Lord of the Rings Online include the Dourhands.