User blog comment:WitchKingofMorgul/Black Arrow theory/@comment-5419359-20130319043546

This a an interesting idea. I had always thought that the iron was used up in the making of the two swords but that was never explicitly stated. I usually dont go out for theories but you did a great job crafting this theory. However, long ages spperate the two stories and i feel that the time alone makes the idea a strech. But is was a great theory all the same and has given me much to think about. Good Job!