User blog comment:Gcheung28/A Middle-Earth Character Tree/@comment-5318101-20121222050505/@comment-5318101-20121224011353

oh wait wait wait. So smaug stole dale (which is underground or above??) and the dwarves fled, and now thorin wants it back, the whole city, not just the treasure? WAIT  is Dale inside the mountain and all of the treasure was there, and smaug stole the treasure AND Dale? And so thorin wants ALL of it back, right? Where are all the dwarves now? ANd why did thorin only make a big deal about the treasure? that's how it seemed to me...