User blog comment:LotrNERD/Who Would Win?/@comment-87.112.160.107-20120730225725

The Gandalf from the books would win hands down. But Peter Jackson made Gandalf WAY to underpowered in the movies. In the scene when he confronts the Witch-King (in the Extended Edition of Return of the King), the Witch-King simply destroys Gandalf's staff and then moves in for the kill. The Witch-King is simply a Man. He could never defeat a Maia spirit like Gandalf. Judging the film's approach I would probably say Legoloas would win because he is so agile and can shoot form long distances.