Forum:Gil-Galad

Gil-Galad

Even though Gil-Galad is mentiond in the Silmarillion as the son of Fingon, Christopher Tolkien has stated he's not. He's the son of Orodreth. It is also stated that none of the 4th generation of the House of Finwë went to Beleriand other than Idril and Orodreth. In other articles such as Ñoldor the right version is given. This needs to be cleaned up, because this makes this site Inconsistent. So either the true version should be on this site or the Silmarillion version. EvilHeroDarkGaia 09:51, November 21, 2010 (UTC)